Art beyond sight?

July 16, 2013 • Posted in blindness, Uncategorized by

An organization called Art Beyond Sight is working with the Chicago History Museum to learn more about ways people who are blind manage in museums, and I’ve been invited to head over there this Thursday morning to offer suggestions.

Confession: I’m always ambivalent about these things. I credit the institutions for trying. I really do. And some special accommodations–like the advance tour before plays at Steppenwolf — truly enriched my experience. But when it comes to static, visual art, I must confess I’ve been to several accessible exhibits and none have been particularly satisfying or enlightening.

Mind you, I’m not speaking for all visually impaired people. And I’m never one to turn down special privileges, like the ability to touch artifacts that the general public cannot. But for me, touching artifacts does not allow me to appreciate the entire exhibition. It only provides some of the pieces, and hey, I already spend too much time putting mental puzzles together every day.

As for audio tours, well, they can be quite entertaining and educational, yes, but paying to get into a museum just to walk around with headphones on doesn’t make sense to me. I’d rather download the monologue and listen to it at home, lying comfortably on my couch!

I do like living in a big city with lots of museums. I get a lot out of it without being able to see. I attend lectures and read books to learn about exhibitions in town, about the artists and their lives and their significance. I enjoy discussing the exhibitions with sighted friends who go see them, but as for the special tactile things, I confess that they:

  • Expect too much. Touch is too particular — I can only take in parts of the artwork that are one fingertip wide
  • Make the sighted people feel better about the Braille signs and tactile exhibits than I do
  • Leave me feeling obligated to be grateful

But, again–I applaud the effort, and because I’ve been wrong more than once in the past, I figure they asked, so I’ll answer. And in the process, I’ll be forced to climb back on the horse, er, bus…It was colder out the last time I waited for a busOne of the many, many things I’ve had to avoid since my unexpected emergency open-heart surgery is riding a bus alone with my Seeing eye dog. Surgeons were afraid the bus would take off before we found a seat and I’d fall. Not good for my healing sternum.

This Thursday marks 12 weeks since my April miracle. My sternum is healed now, and the #22 bus is an easy ride from our place to the Chicago History Museum. I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t a bit anxious about the bus trip, and a post my writer friend Jeff Flodin just published called Every trip an adventure is not boosting my confidence, either (it’s about trying to find a seat on CTA buses with his Seeing Eye dog Randy). And so, rather than think about bus rides and well-meaning accessible exhibits, I’m focusing on my reward instead: I’m meeting friends at the museum afterwards for lunch. No special accomodations necessary for that: my four remaining senses are enough to feel the air-conditioning, smell the coffee, taste the food and hear lively conversation.

Monna Ray On July 16, 2013 at 3:58 pm

Dear Beth, Your comments are so appropriate. But I guess you can’t blame those who want to be helpful. Tell your truth and do enjoy lunch. Monna

James Paradiso On July 16, 2013 at 4:03 pm

Hey Professor Beth! Hope all’s well with you. All the best, Par

bethfinke On July 20, 2013 at 9:17 am

Manna and Jim, thanks for your good wishes. And yes, I *did* enjoy lunch!

Jim On July 16, 2013 at 6:43 pm

I always read your blog. Always. I read it out loud to Judy. Out loud is better. It makes it alive. The next book is in there. I here it. Judy says “Can’t wait to see you guys”.

bethfinke On July 20, 2013 at 9:19 am

Thanks for the encouragement about the next book. I’m working on one, I promise! Progress a bit slow, though, so like I say, your encouragement is very much appreciated…

Jeff Flodin On July 17, 2013 at 7:17 am

Thank you, Beth, for so sensitively expressing the ambivalence of appreciating a thoughtful gesture (the museum that solicits input from blind patrons) versus the reality that these concessions/enhancements usually fall short of equal enjoyment. Yes, audio descriptions of static art works are helpful, but it just ain’t the same as seeing it. And we are not ungrateful for the effort to accommodate. Sometimes, sadly, the twain don’t meet.

susie cronin On July 18, 2013 at 11:28 am

Hi Beth! I love the way you think ( and write!). I play with my art (small sculptures) a lot and I wonder how you might play in general. Maybe you have already written on the topic, but if not, I would be interested in learning more from you. So glad to hear that you are mending so well. I think of you often! XXO Susie

bethfinke On July 20, 2013 at 9:33 am

Oh, Susie, I think of you often, too. I have recovered so well from my scary surgery that I have time now to regret having to cut my time at the Vermont Studio Center short — boohoo. Sure glad I got to know *you* there in the short time I stayed. Love your idea about how I “play” — stay tuned for a future blog post on the subject.

Alicia Caple On July 20, 2013 at 12:13 pm

I am so glad you posted this. Just a couple days ago we took Kayla to the Illinois State Museum and to Lincoln’s Tomb. She loved the museum so much and was thrilled because she was allowed to go up and touch Lincoln’s headstone. Already Kayla has asked to go to different museums so I can’t wait to see how your experience goes!

bethfinke On July 24, 2013 at 8:51 am

So good to hear from you – I love hearing this story about the fabulous Kayla!
One thing I learned during my time at the Chicago History Museum is that a lot of Chicagoans who are blind recommend the Chicago Art Institute and its special programming for people with visual impairments:
http://www.artic.edu/visit/accessibility

I hope to check this out myself sometime in the next couple of months, and when I do, I will publish a post about my visit to the Art Institute here.
Also heard a rumor that people who are blind or have a visual impairment get a discount on admission, and so do their sighted guide, but I wasn’t able to find anything out about that on the web site.

Evan On July 23, 2013 at 10:03 am

This is a helpful post, especially the line about “leaving me obligated to be grateful.” I’m going to steal that, if you don’t mind.

bethfinke On July 24, 2013 at 8:56 am

Be my guest, happy to share!

Leave a Response