Let's ask Miss Manners

August 11, 2012 • Posted in Beth Finke, blindness, Uncategorized by

The orientation packet they sent out for the Summer Military Sport Camp I’m volunteering at includes a primer on disability etiquette. Among other things, the two-page document suggests that if the situation is appropriate, we should “strike up a conversation and include the person in whatever is going on, just as you would do for an average-looking person.” I’ve read documents like this before (I work part-time at Easter Seals Headquarters, and they feature a similar list of guidelines on their web site). I am sure the people who devise these guidelines mean well, but do they realize that their well-intentioned lists might leave a person with a disability feeling, well, like they’re talking to a person who is nervous about talking to them?

The antidote? A list of do’s and don’ts that turns the notion of disability etiquette on its head. I appreciated this parody so much when I first read it that I thought the time was right to resurrect it.

What To Do when You Meet a Sighted Person
People who use their eyes to acquire information about the world are called sighted people or “people who are sighted.” Legal “sight” means any visual acuity greater than 20/200 in the better eye without correction or an angle of vision wider than 20 degrees. Sighted people enjoy rich, full, lives, as they work, play, and raise families. They run businesses, hold public offices, and teach your children.

Sighted people cannot function well in low lighting conditions and are usually helpless in total darkness. Their homes are usually brightly lit at great expense, as are businesses that cater to the sighted consumer.

How Can I Best Communicate with Sighted People?
Sighted people are accustomed to viewing the world in visual terms. This means that in many situations, they will not be able to communicate orally and may resort to pointing or other gesturing. They may also use subtle facial expressions to convey feelings in social situations. Calmly alert the sighted person to his or her surroundings by speaking slowly, in a normal tone of voice. There is no need to raise your voice when addressing a sighted person.

How Do Sighted People Get Around?
People who are sighted may walk or ride public transportation, but most choose to travel long distances by operating their own motor vehicles, usually one passenger to a car. They have gone through many hours of extensive training to learn the rules of the road in order to further their independence. Once that road to freedom has been mastered, sighted people earn a legal classification and a driver’s license, which allows them to operate a private vehicle relatively safely and independently.

How Can I Assist a Sighted Person?
At times, sighted people may need help finding things, especially when operating a motor vehicle. Your advance knowledge of routes and landmarks, particularly bumps in the road, turns, and traffic lights, will assist the “driver” in finding the way quickly and easily. Your knowledge of building layouts can also assist the sighted person in navigating complex shopping malls and offices. Sighted people tend to be very proud and will not ask directly for assistance. Be gentle, yet firm.

How Do Sighted People Read?Sighted people read via a system called “print.” Print is a series of images drawn in a two-dimensional plane. Because the person who is sighted relies exclusively on visual information, his or her attention span tends to fade quickly when reading long texts. People who are sighted generally have a poorly developed sense of touch. Braille is completely foreign to the sighted person and he or she will take longer to learn the code and be severely limited by his or her existing visual senses.

How Do Sighted People Use Computers?
Computer information is presented to sighted people in a “Graphical User Interface” or GUI. Sighted people often suffer from hand-eye coordination problems. To accommodate this difficulty, people who are sighted use a “mouse,” a handy device that slides along the desk top to save confusing keystrokes. With one button, the sighted person can move around his or her computer screen quickly and easily.
People who are sighted are not accustomed to synthetic speech and may have great difficulty understanding even the clearest synthesizer. Be patient and be prepared to explain many times how your computer equipment works.

How Can I Support a Sighted Person?
People who are sighted do not want your charity. They want to live, work and play alongside you on an equal basis. The best thing you can do to support sighted people in your community is to open yourself to their world. These citizens are vital contributing members of the community, real people with thoughts and feelings, hopes and dreams, and a story to tell. Take a sighted person to lunch today!

Kris On August 11, 2012 at 6:58 pm

I love it! Totally hilarious!

Kim On August 11, 2012 at 7:13 pm

Too funny! Thanks for posting this.

Judy On August 11, 2012 at 7:25 pm

Funny and thought-provoking too.

bethfinke On August 12, 2012 at 8:52 pm

Relieved that you, my beloved blog readers, understood that this was published with humor in mind — was afraid that it might sound snarky, or, worse than that, bitter.

Kim On August 11, 2012 at 7:26 pm

Ugh, just read the “disability etiquette” rules at Easter Seals. It’s disturbing in so many ways. Several years ago, I spent 8 months using a wheelchair due to an injury. I couldn’t believe how many people treated me like I was intellectually deficient because I couldn’t walk. So embarrassing for them!

Carl On August 11, 2012 at 10:20 pm

This is great. Do you know who wrote it?

bethfinke On August 12, 2012 at 9:01 pm

When I first read this parody it was attributed to “Author Unknown” but a bit of research tells me that the author is probably Kent Ireton, the Regional Manager at Idaho Division of Vocational Rehabilitation in Boise. If anyone out there can confirm this, please do!

kellyz On August 11, 2012 at 10:32 pm

This is fantastic! I hope I can find a way to use this with an upper level elementary class when I student teach next semester. Thanks again, Beth, for providing some awesome thought-provoking work!

bethfinke On August 12, 2012 at 9:04 pm

Kelly, if you figure out a way to share this with upper level elementary school kids and you are willing to share your idea, I’d love to hear it – I visit upper-level elementary school kids from time to time and maybe I could use this list with them too.

Jeff Flodin On August 12, 2012 at 6:49 am

Thank you, Beth, for this reminder that all is relative. I do get a kick out of the suggestion that you involve a disabled person in a conversation “as if they were average-looking.” Let us blind folk strive to become average!

bethfinke On August 12, 2012 at 9:08 pm

So difficult for we blind people to do when we know we are all above average looking, Jeff.

Nora On August 12, 2012 at 8:55 am

Hmmmm. Sometimes you just have to scratch your head and wonder what people are thinking.

becky On August 12, 2012 at 2:09 pm

Ha – I have read this before and laugh each time. So true. One of my favorite handouts has the heading “How to treat a person with a disability” and if I am remembering right then repeatedly on the rest of the page it says … like a person.

I understand for some a few pointers on how to do sighted guide or something can be helpful and ask if needed … but really it is pretty simple, isn’t it! No manual needed!

DNM On August 13, 2012 at 1:50 am

Color me humorless but a brief chuckle at Ireton’s brilliant cultural inversion was followed by a rueful realization of how very wrong its assertion that the difference between ability and disability is at base a matter of point of view, and even more its tacit assertion that social change is primarily contingent on attitudinal change. Would that this were so! The second-class status of PWDs is, rather, a mirror of the power relationship between TABs and PWDs: thems with the power get to legislate normalcy and deviance.

Thus, for example, sightlessness is not just the opposite of sightedness but the opposite of normalcy. Thus, too, Jewish and Italian Americans talk loudly and with their hands while Mid-Westerners talk normally; African American given names tend to the “creative” while European American given names tend to the normal. Our majority culture is rich (in several senses) and most often kind, generous, democratic, welcoming—as ethical a culture as the world has known—but it is only as ethical as it wishes to be and no more so. Let PWDs demand true economic and social equality and see how quickly and, if necessary, brutally hegemony asserts itself. The struggle advances not through changing attitudes as much as through hard-won shifts in institutional power.

bethfinke On August 13, 2012 at 7:48 am

Appreciate this thought-provoking comment, DNM. Can’t speak for others, but I sure don’t color you humorless. I color you wise. And analytical.
Sidenote to some other blog readers: the letters “PWD” used in DNM’s comment above stand for “people with Disabilities.”

Audrey Mitchell On August 13, 2012 at 7:36 am

When you think you know everything, you learn something else!

bethfinke On August 13, 2012 at 7:49 am

Aha! Another great comment from one of my wise blog readers. I suppose the trick is to never assume we know everything, that way we can continue to learn.

Kim On August 13, 2012 at 7:46 am

What’s a TAB?

bethfinke On August 13, 2012 at 7:51 am

I believe it stands for “Temporarily Able-Bodied,” as in, everyone is going to become a person with a disability someday. ThisTAB concept is a term I have never liked, but it would take me far too long to explain why that is. Perhaps fodder for a future blog post…?

Kim On August 13, 2012 at 8:23 am

DNM made some good points (now that I understand the jargon). Does “Temporarily Able-Bodied” only include visible, physical disabilities? I don’t like that PWD vs. TAB encourages a divisive, us-them, mentality.
You may have to start publishing a key with your posts. As I’ve said before, I always learn something reading your blog. Thanks Beth!

Deborah Darsie On August 13, 2012 at 1:11 pm

I love the ‘twist’ of perspective. There is a sad presumption in rules as presented in the Easter Seals ‘guide’. That perspective should be considered outdated and needs to be revised.

Thanks for the informative blog postings!

bethfinke On August 13, 2012 at 2:35 pm

You’re welcome, and thank *you* for leaving a comment, I love reading the comments to my blog posts. The Easter Seals web site is do for a redesign soon, I will do my best to let the powers that be there know they need to either redo or eliminate that “disability etiquette” page. Wish me luck!

Judy Spock On August 13, 2012 at 6:47 pm

Nice irony in this! Judy Spock

bethfinke On August 14, 2012 at 7:28 am

I agree! Depending on how it had been written, the list could have been thought of as orny. Or petulant. Or bitter. But I think the writer got it, well…just right.

Flip It « The Empty Pen On August 15, 2012 at 12:12 am

[…] friend Beth (you may know her from the comments) wrote a terrific post that turned etiquette on it’s head. Well, maybe not etiquette itself, but certainly how people perceive the world around them. As a […]

Benita Black On August 15, 2012 at 11:40 am

Ya mean I *don’t* have to talk louder to sighted people? But what if they don’t speak English?

Leave a Response