I am pleased to feature Bindy Bitterman as our Saturdays with Seniors guest blogger today. Bindy owned and managed Eureka, an amazing and eclectic little shop in Evanston, Illinois until 2015, when she retired at age 84. She moved to The Admiral at the Lake after that, and is a writer in the memoir class I lead there via Zoom. This Wednesday, November 11, is Veteran’s Day, so I thought it the perfect time to publish this story Bindy wrote about befriending a few veterans during World War II.
So Long to A Beautiful Friendship with an Unlikely Beginning
by Bindy Bitterman
I wish I could find the Chicago Tribune photo: 5 8th graders in 1944. We’d had a rummage sale, and raised enough money to donate a radio/phonograph to the Jewish USO downtown AND sponsor a breakfast there. What a day that was! Marty, Mel, and Al were there, three sailors from New York who’d been assigned teaching duties at Navy Pier. I never saw Al after that day, but Marty and I would become wartime pen pals as he moved on to other tasks at other destinations. And Mel! Gorgeous, wonderful Mel — our connection lasted until he died this year.
From its beginnings on that Sunday in 1944, our friendship expanded to include parents, spouses, and kids, mine and his. It reached from the suburbs of New York, where my husband Richard and I visited them, to our home in Chicago’s Rogers Park, where they visited us. It still continues with his wife, Helen, and his musician son.
I said gorgeous and I meant it. Mel was gorgeous into his 90s, and maybe he still was when he died. But that’s a minor part of his wonderfulness: he was dear. He was deep. He was kind. He was a great father and a great friend. He took life seriously but laughed throughout it. He and Helen loved kids, and when they came to visit ours, they brought their guitar and their kid-friendly songs and jokes and riddles and tongue-twisters (not all of them music to MY ears; some I thought a bit too vulgar). Of course, my kids loved every one of them. And they adored Mel and Helen.
That first day we met, I had taken the three sailors home with me to meet my parents. My mother, all charm and graciousness, immediately won their hearts. A bond developed. Shortly thereafter, when Mel married Helen and brought her to Chicago, the couple started visiting frequently. During a phone conversation Just a month or so ago, Helen reminisced about my parents and their lovely Chicago apartment.
Yes, we’re still in touch. I drop her a line or two on my prettiest note cards every few weeks now.
Because I didn’t for a while.
When my husband Richard died, Mel and Helen were still healthy. But they moved into an assisted living facility in their Long Island area, and shortly thereafter, Mel began showing gradual signs of dementia. I couldn’t bear to think of either of them, but especially Mel, in that condition, but I kept calling every few months as I had done through the years. After a while, though, it became too painful. No calls, no notes.
Their son phoned a few months ago. Mel was gone. A piece of my heart went, too.
But Helen and I are back in touch. She and Mel were married 77 years, I think. She’s well into her 90s, too, but seems pretty chipper.
Didn’t someone in our group say something about putting your sad thoughts in a basket? I need a trunk!
Beth, thanks for this. I’ve read about Bindy in the Tribune and seen other references by you, but this piece (of course I was especially touched by her description of Mel) and the video tell an even greater story. She is passionate, smart, funny and, to my liking, a little bit naughty. What a perfect combination. It is totally understandable why she has had so many beautiful and life-long friendships.
Bindy, what beautiful memories you have of such special people in your life.
Bindy,
I was in the GeNarrations class with you during the summer of 2019. It is quite lovely to be reacquainted with you and your stories.
This really tugged at my heart!
I’m so glad the story resonated with many of you; thank you so much for these warm comments. Beth also include a video of me in my 35-year antiques shop in Evanston, Il. It looks like an ad, but it isn’t. If you didn’t see it, it’s to the immediate right of the memoir, and the headline is JAY SHEFSKY–he’s the TV guy who made and broadcast the video. It gives a whole new slant on he writer!
Bindy, I just watched the video. I wish I could go to your shop and spend a week or two there! Everything you showed to Jay resonated with me. Your collections brought me JOY, a rare commodity these days.
Regarding your essay: why was there a need for a Jewish USO? Were there other “specific” USO’s?
Best wishes from Beth’s NYC friend, Benita
I’ve never thought about this before. Things were so different then, and I doubt there were any other sizable groups that could have financed a USO. Blacks certainly couldn’t have, (and come to think of it, I wonder if they were even allowed in the regular USO!). I don’t think we had any other major groups in Chicago—certainly no Muslims or Hispanics to speak of . (I clearly remember being downtown as a college graduate—1952—and looking forward to a visit to San Francisco for the first time, so bored with the uniformity of Chicago! I was dying to see Asian faces or anything that wasn’t dull and white like we were here!)
This may interest you: Having had that antiques shop for almost 35 years (from the l980s to 2015) it took almost all that time for me to realize that what I considered just fun, funky Black kitchen accessories from the 50s and before might be considered demeaning to Black people. I mean, I ARGUED the point! When you grow up and “that’s just the way things are” and there is no movement to counteract that……you go with the flow!
I’m so glad you asked that question! Made me think! Thank you!
I just realized I only answered the last part of your question. It was probably partly because, to put it simply, Jews were pretty much not very welcome in the armed services in WW2. I wonder if they are now! (In fact, it was an open secret that Jews were not very welcome in the U.S.!!! There are tons of examples,including Jewish refugee children not being allowed here because of anti-semitism. I’m pretty sure FDR and Eleanor, especially, wanted to let them in, but Washington and all the money would have pressured him otherwise.)
If you’ve seen any movies from that period (probably made by Jewish men) there’s often a mouthy Jew from Brooklyn who starts out universally hated and made a butt of pretty scary “jokes” by his fellow soldiers who proves his bravery or his skill in something or other (possibly hoodwinking the enemy, even if the enemy is part of our armed serves!) and winds up a beloved hero!
Hope this answers both your questions!
Bindy
Leave a Response